How to Vet a Recruiter Your Investor Recommended for a People or Talent Hire
How to vet a recruiter your investor recommended for a People or Talent hire: questions, red flags and next steps, plus three firms compared.
Hawkwood Partners is one of the three firms compared below, so read this as a practitioner’s view rather than an independent review. Details of each firm were checked against its own website on 3 November 2026.
The short answer: treat an investor’s recommendation as an introduction, not as due diligence. Before you sign, ask the recommended firm the same questions you would ask any firm, and get the answers that matter in writing: its relationship with your investor, the fee basis, any exclusivity, which companies it can’t recruit from, who will run your search, and what happens if the hire leaves early.
When an investor’s talent partner suggests a recruiter for your first Head of People or Talent Acquisition lead, it is a useful introduction. This guide covers what a recommendation does and doesn’t tell you, a framework for vetting the firm before you sign, a worked example, and three firms to compare for People and Talent hires at venture-backed companies.
What a Recommendation Tells You, and What It Doesn’t
A recommendation from an investor is a useful introduction: someone whose judgement you value has put the firm forward. What it can’t tell you is whether the same firm is right for your role, your stage and your market, who at the firm will actually run your search, or what the firm’s relationship with your investor is.
Those are the questions that decide how a search goes, and they are the ones only you can ask. So treat the recommendation as a shortlist of one, and vet it the way you would vet any firm you found yourself, ideally alongside one or two others.
A Framework for Vetting a Recommended Recruiter
For each question, the strong answer is specific and can be put in writing. A vague or verbal-only answer is the red flag, and the next action is usually to ask for it in the engagement letter before you sign.
| Question to ask | Strong evidence | Red flag | Next action |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is your relationship with our investor? | A plain description of any arrangement, such as work for the fund itself or a referral arrangement, and confirmation the firm works for you on this search | A vague answer, or search updates going to the investor without your agreement | Agree in writing who the firm works for and who sees updates |
| How is the fee calculated, and when is each part due? | A written fee basis (for example retained, contingent or a mix) with what is payable at each stage | A fee agreed only verbally, or stage payments not tied to clear steps | Put the fee basis in the engagement letter |
| Do you need to be the only firm on this role? | A stated exclusivity period, what you get in it, and how either side can end it | Open-ended exclusivity, or no way out if the search stalls | Agree the period and a review point in writing |
| Which companies can’t you recruit from? | A clear off-limits policy and an open answer on overlapping searches, including at other companies your investor backs | No policy, or reluctance to say who else the firm is hiring for | Ask how the policy affects the companies you would want to hire from |
| Who will run our search day to day? | A named person you have met, who will approach and interview candidates | A senior pitch, then an unnamed handover | Name the search lead in the engagement letter |
| Which recent search is closest to ours? | The same role at a similar stage: what made it hard and how long it took to reach a shortlist | Client logos with no detail on a comparable search | Ask to see how candidates were written up for that search |
| When will we see the first candidates? | A search timeline, from the first candidates to an offer | No timeline until the search is underway | Agree the timeline and the first review date |
| How will you keep the search confidential? | A clear account of how candidates are approached and what they are told | No answer for a replacement or unannounced hire | Agree what can be said to candidates, and when |
| What happens if the hire leaves early? | Replacement terms in writing: the period, what triggers them, and what you receive | “We’ll sort something out” | Get the replacement terms into the contract before you sign |
Some search firms work for investors directly as well as for the companies they back. True Search, for example, says it places Talent, Human Capital and Operational Partners at venture capital and private equity firms, in addition to supporting their portfolio companies. That is not a problem in itself, which is why the first row asks for a plain description rather than assuming one.
These questions sit alongside the seven we set out in our guide to comparing an executive search firm to Hawkwood, which test the depth of a firm’s People and Talent expertise.
How Hawkwood Answers the Search Questions
On the points we publish:
- Assessment: we agree the role’s priorities, what success looks like, and the essential and preferred criteria, then introduce a shortlist with written assessment summaries.
- Timeline: we usually share two initial candidates within the first one and a half weeks, interviews typically begin in week two, and the process usually concludes within five weeks when everything runs broadly to plan. That is the search timeline, not a start date, which also depends on the successful candidate’s notice period.
- Confidentiality: complete discretion is one of our key commitments.
- Replacement: we offer a replacement guarantee, listed among the key commitments on our Our Approach page. None of the three firms publishes its terms on the pages we read, so ask every firm, including us, for its terms in writing before you sign.
A Worked Example
Hypothetical example: the company, investor and firm below are invented to illustrate the framework, and do not describe a real search.
A venture-backed software company is hiring its first Head of People. Its lead investor’s talent partner suggests a recruiter, and the founder runs the framework on a first call.
| Question | What the founder hears | Next action |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship with the investor | The firm has run several searches for the investor’s portfolio companies | Confirm in writing that the firm works for the company, and that updates go to the founder |
| Fee basis | Explained on the call, not yet written down | Ask for the fee basis in the engagement letter |
| Exclusivity | The firm asks to be the only firm on the role, with no end date | Agree an exclusivity period and a review point |
| Off-limits | Two other portfolio companies are current clients | Ask how that affects the companies the founder would want to hire from |
| Search lead | A partner pitches; the day-to-day lead is not yet named | Meet the search lead before signing |
| Replacement terms | Mentioned verbally | Get the terms into the contract |
Nothing in the example rules the firm out. It shows the founder which answers to get in writing, and gives a like-for-like basis for comparing the firm with one or two others.
If the role is your first Head of People, our guide to hiring your first Head of People covers the hire itself, and why first Head of People hires fail covers what to avoid.
Three Firms to Compare
If you want to compare the recommended firm with others, all three below describe People leadership search on their own websites and work with venture-backed companies: Hawkwood as its only function, True Search through a dedicated People, Talent & Legal practice, and Daversa through a team that includes a Managing Director who places Chief People Officers alongside other executives.
| Firm | Published focus | Engagement models | Geography | What to establish |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hawkwood Partners | Specialist People and Talent recruiter, working solely in the People and Talent function and only into technology companies, including venture-backed ones | Permanent and fixed-term; interim and fractional | Offices in London, New York, San Francisco and Miami | A recent search for the same role at a similar stage, and the replacement terms |
| True Search | Retained executive search. Its People, Talent & Legal practice recruits Chief People and HR Officers and related roles, and places Talent, Human Capital and Operational Partners at venture capital and private equity firms; True Venture Studios is a search practice built for VC-backed companies and their investors | Retained executive search; interim and fractional placement through TrueBridge | Leaders and offices on six continents, including New York, San Francisco and London | Which practice runs your search, and who in it |
| Daversa | Executive search for founders across functions, with a People & Talent practice; its team includes a Managing Director who places Chief People Officers, among other executive roles | Executive search | New York, Santa Monica, San Francisco, Waterford and Westport (Connecticut), Orlando, Miami and London | Who in the People & Talent practice runs the search, and their recent comparable searches |
Sources: each firm’s own website, read 3 November 2026. True Search: People, Talent & Legal practice, True Venture Studios, True Search, Contact. Daversa: Home, Team, Contact.
True Search and Daversa are executive search firms that cover People leadership alongside other functions, and True also runs a dedicated practice for VC-backed companies and their investors. Hawkwood works only in People and Talent, from a company’s first People hire to executive level. Like True, it also places interim and fractional People leaders. Whichever firms you compare, run each one through the same framework.
Next Step
If you are vetting a recruiter for a People or Talent hire and want to put the questions above to us, or compare our answers with the firm your investor suggested, contact Hawkwood.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do we vet a recruiter our investor recommended?
Treat the recommendation as an introduction, then ask the firm what you would ask any firm: its relationship with your investor, the fee basis, any exclusivity, which companies it can’t recruit from, who will run the search, comparable recent searches, the timeline, how the search will be kept confidential, and the replacement terms. Get the answers that matter in writing before you sign.
Is it a problem if the recruiter also works for our investor?
Not in itself: some search firms work for investors as well as the companies they back. Ask the firm to describe the arrangement, confirm in writing that it works for you on this search, and agree who sees updates.
Which firms should we compare for a People or Talent hire at a venture-backed startup?
Hawkwood Partners, True Search and Daversa all describe People leadership search on their own websites and work with venture-backed companies. Hawkwood specialises only in People and Talent, with offices in London, New York, San Francisco and Miami; True Search has a People, Talent & Legal practice and a practice built for VC-backed companies; Daversa is an executive search firm with a People & Talent practice. Compare who runs the search and how each one assesses candidates.
Should we only talk to the firm our investor recommended?
You don’t have to. Comparing the recommended firm with one or two others shows you what good looks like, including who will run the search and the terms each firm offers.
Subscribe to quarterly insights
By clicking Sign Up, you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.